Reported Speech: Why Children Write “He Said That I Am Hungry”
7 November 2026 · by Larry
The question says: Ali said, “I am hungry.” Rewrite it in reported speech. Your child writes “Ali said that I am hungry.” Or “Ali said that he am hungry.” Or the closest one of all: “Ali said that he is hungry.” You read it twice and it looks fine, because nothing in it is a spelling mistake or a missing word.
That is why reported speech loses marks quietly. The child usually knows what Ali said. What is missing is the habit of changing two small things at once, the person and the tense, and a third thing, time and place words, that only turns up some of the time.
What the question is really asking
Direct speech is the speaker’s exact words, with speech marks: Ali said, “I am hungry.” Reported speech is you telling someone else what was said, with no speech marks: Ali said that he was hungry.
Nobody is quoting Ali in the second sentence. The speaker is now you, talking about Ali afterwards, so the words have to be rewritten from where you are standing. Three things can move.
Change 1: who is “I”?
In the direct version, I means Ali. In the reported version, someone else is telling the story, so I would mean the wrong person. It becomes he, she or a name.
Siti said, “I can swim.” → Siti said that she could swim.
The question to teach is: “Who is telling this now?” If the answer is not the person who spoke, I has to go. My and your follow the same logic: Ali said, “I lost my pen” becomes Ali said that he had lost his pen.
One exception catches children who have learned “I always changes”. If Ali is the one telling the story later, I stays: “I said that I was hungry.” The word follows the person telling it, not a fixed rule.
Change 2: the tense steps back
The words were spoken in the past, so the verb moves one step back in time.
- am, is → was · are → were
- like, want, need → liked, wanted, needed
- can → could · will → would
- have finished → had finished
The teacher said, “I will collect the books.” → The teacher said that she would collect the books.
A verb that is already in the simple past, like went, is often moved one step further back to had gone. How strictly that is expected in a rewrite exercise is the school’s call, so follow what the teacher has shown rather than what I say here.
Change 3: time and place words
These only matter when the sentence has one, and children forget them because they are not in the part of the sentence they were looking at.
- today → that day · tomorrow → the next day · yesterday → the day before
- now → then · here → there · this → that
Mei said to Ben, “I will help you tomorrow.” becomes Mei told Ben that she would help him the next day. Tomorrow from Mei’s mouth is not tomorrow from the reader’s.
Questions and commands change shape too
Questions and commands are where a child who has the statement pattern still slips.
- A question with a question word: Mum asked, “Where is my phone?” → Mum asked where her phone was. The question mark goes, and the word order goes back to a normal statement: where her phone was, not where was her phone.
- A yes or no question: Mum asked, “Have you eaten?” → Mum asked if I had eaten. (Whether works too.)
- A command: The teacher said, “Open your books.” → The teacher told us to open our books.
Seven slips to listen for
- Keeping the “I”. Ali said that I am hungry. The tense and the person both stayed where they were.
- Changing the person, forgetting the tense. Ali said that he is hungry. This is the closest to right, and the easiest to miss when you mark it.
- Changing the tense, forgetting the person. Ali said that I was hungry. Now the sentence says the writer was hungry.
- Mixing a past verb with a leftover present one. Ali said that he was hungry and wants to eat. Both verbs need to step back: and wanted to eat.
- Leaving the speech marks on. Ali said that “he was hungry.” Those are not Ali’s exact words, so they do not belong in speech marks. (The speech marks piece covers the other half of this.)
- Leaving the question mark and the question order. Mum asked where was her phone? A reported question is no longer a question.
- Said me, said to me. Ali said me that he was tired. Say Ali told me that he was tired, or Ali said that he was tired. The word told needs the listener straight after it; said does not.
What if the thing is still true?
In normal talk, people often keep the present tense when the fact has not changed. “She said she likes durian” is perfectly natural over dinner if she still likes it. Nobody needs correcting at the table. The step-back rule matters in written rewrite questions, where the exercise is built to check whether the child can move the tense. So keep spoken English relaxed and practise the written pattern on paper.
What helps at home
Ask “who is telling this?” first. It fixes the I in a few seconds and leaves the tense as the only job.
Do it out loud, with real sentences. At dinner, say a line (“I am sleepy”) and ask your child to tell a grandparent what you said. Spoken, the tense step comes more easily than on paper, and it makes the written version feel less like a trick.
Underline the verb, then change it. In the direct sentence, have your child underline the verb and circle any I, my, you, today or tomorrow. That is the whole list of things to change. If nothing is underlined or circled, nothing needs to change.
Read the finished sentence for sense. Ali said that I was hungry sounds strange once the child reads it back as if telling you about Ali. The ear catches what the eye skipped.
Do the statements first, questions and commands later. A child who is shaky on he was hungry is not ready for asked where her phone was.
What does not help
- Learning the tense table with no sentences. A child can recite can, could and still write Ali said that he can swim, because the table never met a real sentence.
- “Always change the verb.” It fails when the speaker is reporting something that is still true and the teacher has allowed it, and it does nothing for the pronoun.
- Doing questions and commands before statements are secure. It adds three new patterns to a child still unsure about one.
- Rewriting the whole sentence in your own words. The exercise wants the same meaning in the reported pattern, not a new sentence.
Try it tonight
Made-up sentences. Ask your child to say who is telling the story, then change the person and the verb.
- Siti said, “I am tired.”
- Ali said, “I have lost my pen.”
- Mei said to Ben, “I will help you.”
- Mum asked, “Where is my phone?”
- The teacher said, “Open your books.”
One way to answer: Siti said that she was tired · Ali said that he had lost his pen · Mei told Ben that she would help him · Mum asked where her phone was · The teacher told us to open our books. If your child gets three of five, the pattern is mostly there. Go back to the one that went wrong and say it aloud before writing it down.
A note on how it is marked
How reported speech is tested in a paper is set by the school and the MOE syllabus, which you can check at moe.gov.sg. If the teacher has shown you a particular way to set it out, or has said when the tense may stay as it is, go by that over anything you read online, this piece included.
An honest note on StudyLab as well: its free English practice has a Reported Speech topic in its Primary 6 list. It shows a line such as Ali said, “I am tired” and asks the child to choose the correct reported version, so both the person and the tense have to be right. I have not checked that it covers questions or commands. Try it at the English practice, and see the English guide by level for where it sits among the other topics.
Related reading
Reported speech is one of the patterns that rewrite questions are built from, covered in rewrite the sentence questions. The speech marks that reported speech does not use are in speech marks in composition, and the person-word choice behind the first change is in I or me. Another rewrite that changes the verb and keeps the meaning is active and passive voice.
Keeping one tense through a whole story, apart from what people say, is in tense slipping in a story.
Quick answers
What is reported speech? Telling someone what a person said, without quoting the exact words and without speech marks. Ali said that he was hungry.
Why does “I” change to “he” or “she”? Because the person telling the story is now someone else. Ask who is telling it now.
Why does “am” become “was”? The words were spoken in the past, so the verb steps one step back in time. Can becomes could and will becomes would.
Do speech marks stay in reported speech? No. Reported speech is not the exact words, so there are no speech marks.
Does a reported question keep its question mark? No. Mum asked where her phone was. It is a statement about a question, and the word order goes back to normal.
Try the free English practice →