๐ท $500 a month for 5 years: a simple first plan
What I tell beginners, and what 33 years of real S&P 500 history says about it
By Larry ยท 3 November 2026
Friends keep asking me how to start. My answer is always the same: keep it boring. One broad fund, a fixed amount every month, and patience. Before I posted this, I tested my own advice against real market history, and here's what it shows, good and bad.
1. Start with one broad fund
For beginners I suggest VOO, which tracks the S&P 500, the 500 biggest companies in the US. One fund, and you own a small slice of all of them.
2. The plan: $500 a month for 60 months
Monthly is enough. In my test, buying daily, weekly or monthly ended within about 1โ2% of each other, and monthly keeps fees tiny. A $500 order buys less than one VOO share, so on Tiger it's charged as a fractional trade: 1% capped at US$1, plus GST, about US$1.09 an order. That's roughly US$65 over the 60 months, about 0.2% of what you put in.
3. If you also keep some cash: have a dip plan
Don't buy the dip at random. If you'd like some money ready for bad days, split the $500:
- $350 a month into the fund, and $150 a month into a cash pot (T-bills or a fixed deposit).
- Market falls 20% from its high โ put half the pot into the fund.
- Market falls 30% from its high โ put half of what's left in.
The plan resets once the market makes a new high. The honest result: it made the bad patches gentler, but over 5 and 10 years it usually ended a bit lower (about 5โ7% behind) than putting the full $500 in every month. Use it if the cash helps you sleep and stick with the plan, not to beat the market.
What history says
I tested $500 a month into SPY (it tracks the same index as VOO and has a longer history), with dividends reinvested after the 30% US withholding and after Tiger fees. Cash earns the 3-month US T-bill rate. Real data from 1993 to 2 Nov 2026.
| Start | Fund: after 5 yrs | Fund: after 10 yrs | Cash only: 5 / 10 yrs | With dip pot: 5 / 10 yrs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 2000 peak | $32.6k | $34.8k | $31.3k / $35.6k | $32.2k / $35.1k |
| Oct 2007 peak | $38.5k | $72.9k | $30.1k / $30.4k | $36.4k / $62.0k |
| Jan 2008 | $39.1k | $77.2k | $30.1k / $30.5k | $36.7k / $64.8k |
| Jan 2015 | $42.2k | $80.1k | $31.2k / $35.1k | $40.2k / $78.4k |
| Feb 2020 peak | $45.5k | $56.6k today | $32.9k / โ | $43.1k / โ |
| Jan 2022 peak | $43.6k today (58 months, $29k in) | $32.1k today | $40.5k today | |
$30,000 put in over 60 months. "Today" = 2 Nov 2026.
- After 5 years (346 start months since 1993): the typical result was about $39,500 for the $30,000 put in. But about 1 in 7 (14.5%) ended below $30k. The worst was $17,500, for starts in the late 1990s and mid-2000s that ran into a crash near the end.
- After 10 years (286 start months): typical about $55,500, and only about 1 in 26 (3.8%) was still below $30k. Time matters more than timing.
- On the way, expect red. At its worst point, the typical start was 22% down on the money put in. The worst case was 45% down, in 2009. That's normal, and it's when the monthly buys pick up cheap units.
- Cash only never lost money, but it grew to only about $31,400 after 5 years and $34,100 after 10. Once in a while it wins, though. Starting at the 2000 peak, cash was slightly ahead even after 10 years.
- Putting the $30k in on day one usually ended higher (about $50,400 after 5 years), but it had a bigger chance of a loss (18.5%) and fell as much as 55%.
My takeaway: $500 a month is a great way to start. Give it at least 5 years, and ideally 10. Don't stop when the market is down, because that's the part that works for you.
Try your own numbers in the Piggy Bank calculator โ
โ Larry ๐ท
How I tested it
Daily SPY prices and dividends from Yahoo Finance (Jan 1993โ2 Nov 2026). Dividends reinvested after 30% US withholding. Tiger SG fees at today's schedule: about US$1.09 for an order under one share, about US$2.19 for one share or more (older years, when SPY was cheaper). Cash earns the 3-month US T-bill rate (^IRX). Buys are on the same day each month for 60 months, then held. Dip pot: half the pot at โ20% from SPY's all-time high, half of the rest at โ30%, once per fall, reset after a new high. No currency moves (results in US$). Sources: IRS (US estate tax for non-residents), Vanguard research on cost averaging, Tiger Brokers SG fees, Tiger auto-invest FAQ.
Home โข Piggy Bank calculator โข Privacy โข Terms